Smith & Wesson the best 1911 value for the money and their customer service is BETTER than anyone elses, even Colt's. Copyright Complaints: Please direct DMCA Takedown Notices to the registered agent: cliffjr83 I own a Colt CCO "Concealed Carry Officer", basically a Colt Commander on an officers frame. To get an idea of just how tiny these things are the typical contemporary service pistol has a front sight about .130”wide. what is the difference in that scandinam vs reg blued? The 1911 was probably carried just that way by some in the early days regardless of how Browning had designed it. When revolvers ruled, the big argument was over Colt vs Smith & Wesson. The 686 is stainless. Forum Reviews Rules Legal Site ... Dan Wessons are more of a "traditional" 1911 with internal extractors (only real difference) but appear to be well built guns. While I wouldn't willingly choose either in a situation today, I’m confident that both could still be pressed into emergency service and carry the day. The platform’s title is a dead giveaway to the year the gun went into production but did you know there’s a cool backstory, too? The Colt genuinely surprised me here. Triggers … . There both fine weapons but if i had to choose one i guess id go colt. The finish is beautiful. ready at 10 yards              High (seconds)            Low(seconds)              Average(seconds), M1911                                     4.36                            3.62                                    4.01, M1917                                    5.07                             4.0                                      4.57. This email link is to reach site administrators for assistance, if you cannot access TFL via other means. This is an advantage, we felt. by Lt. Col. J.W. If you are a TFL member and can access TFL, please do not use this link; instead, use the forums (like Questions, Suggestions, and Tech Support) or PM an appropriate mod or admin. Starting with both hands on the handgun at chest level the weapons were pushed out at maximum speed and fired; three shots at the closest 3-yard target, two rounds into the target at 5 yards, and a single round into the 7-yard silhouette. A big change occurred with the introduction of the Smith and Wesson Military and Police .38 revolver. I can knock down targets at 150 yards!!! Whether in the Argonne Forest, a muddy trench, or a rubbled German alleyway a generation later the ability to stop the enemy at arms’ length gives the sidearm its legitimacy. It was quickly answered by a similar gun from Smith & Wesson. Colt hasn’t really broken any ground in the 1911 world in the past 10 years and yet makers like Kimber, Springfield, Dan Wesson, Smith and Wesson, Les Baer, and more unknown groups have continued to make more and more changes without the price of a Wilson. At that point, frankly I'd rather save up a little more cash before buying a Smith and Wesson Performance Center SW1911 or Dan Wesson 1911. Both types stayed in inventory for a very long time and were issued side by side with the massive number of 1911A1s for the greatest generation to carry into the Second World War. The 1917 pointed easily over its crescent shaped front sight and the time to trigger a shot into the circle and follow up with another averaged just under two seconds. I have a 686 Plus and a Colt Detective Special The smith is c. 1996 and the Colt is c. 1994. The best I could squeeze out of the Colt was a bit over 3", again with the Winchester ball, at 25 yards. 1911 Talk: Springfield TRP vs. Smith and Wesson E Series I am a long time lurker and relatively new to shooting. Smith & Wesson PERFORMANCE CENTER® MODEL SW1911 vs Dan Wesson 1911 Special thanks to Sig Sauer for providing the wonderful SIG Elite Performance Ammunition! The parts are then bought by Springfield and shipped back to the states. This probably represents feedback that Browning received from field tests, keeping in mind that many popular firearms of the period used a half cock notch as a safety. Otherwise, I’d have to write an entire book instead. The large frame Smith & Wesson was still a very solid substitute and a viable performer. I would pick the 1911 and step out smartly. I will address only the matter of their respective double-action revolvers. Get the American Rifleman Insider newsletter for at-a-glance access to industry news, gear, gun reviews, videos and more—delivered directly to your Inbox. The rounds were aimed to impact within an 8” circular vital zone and timed from start signal to sixth shot. m&p shield ez pistol important safety recall notice for pistols manufactured between march 1st, 2020 and october 31st, 2020 learn more.. Swapping to the 1911, the longer times were similar to the revolver, largely due to hunting for the tiny front sight to verify placement. ... the SW1911PD is a true (Colt) Commander(tm) size 1911 - with a 4 1/4" barrel/slide - isn't it Kimber and Wilson that make the 4" lengths.? Casual shooting reinforced that notion. The usual result with most loads tried was a 4.5" to 6" spread. Smith & Wesson has long used external extractors on its 1911s, and the company's engineers have this design down pat. The trigger is surprisingly crisp with just a hint of movement and no overtravel. The 1917 bucked with each shot, the 230-gr. As an example on one of the runs the first target had been hit three times in just under a second and the second “attacker” struck twice at 1.46 seconds elapsed. These 1911s sport features that are often added by gun owners as a premium, borderline luxury features. I had purchased one of the 1st production pistols that had the wilson parts in it. Three silhouette targets were laid out in a tight echelon at 3, 5 and 7 yards. The plate rack isn’t tactical, but it does quickly demonstrate how well a pistol handles multiple targets and provides a direct, repeatable comparison. An unwelcome side effect of the long hammer spur is that a large handed shooter who chokes up high on the tang as is popular today creates a pinch point between hammer and the original short grip safety. Only runs with all the hits within the 8” scoring ring counted for record. I set up a 10 x 20 inch steel RSR torso target at 40 yards and logged times and hits for single shots from the ready. Black Hills 230-gr. 40 yards is a long way in pistol land, but a “gimme” shot for even a conscript rifleman and a very dangerous place to be. Times dropped to 2.3 seconds but hit ratio dipped as well.The Smith & Wesson leads in casual comparison with easy groups in the black on standard target centers. Smith & Wesson 1911 E-Series Pistol. There is a small amount of light around the front sight in the notch, which lets a shooter break some satisfying slow fire hits, but it makes cycling the heavy double-action pull while trying to keep the sights aligned a challenge. It is the finest 1911 I own and I have 4. Again, the government specified a “trooper-proof” trigger to curtail accidents. They … They are significantly worse than the sights found on popular service handguns from the years preceding the Colt’s adoption, so there is really no excuse for them. This semi-automatic pistol is a single-action, magazine-fed, recoil-operated handgun, designed to fire .45 ACP rounds. The rimless .45 ACP cartridge was snapped into a metal “half moon” clip to allow ejection, allowing fast reloading of the guns and the individual rounds headspaced on the case to allow single rounds to be chambered if a doughboy lost or damaged his clips. If you still feel you are qualified to post in those subforums, please contact "Shane Tuttle" (the mod for that portion of TFL) via Private Message for assistance. Back in the late 1800’s – and I mean really late, as in 1899 – the United States was involved in a battle with the Moros. However the data was built on a large number of shots over multiple range days and remained consistent. Hits came in as little as 1.07 when everything came together ideally and 1.99 seconds on average. No, For my money I think Colt's are better! You can review the tables and consider if the results tip you one way or another. However, both guns were made with the Great War in full swing and the skilled craftsmen at both factories knew exactly where these guns were going and to what purpose. There’s nothing compact about these brutes.The grips are the other major variation. In that case, ejection was accomplished by a shanks-mare combination of fingernails or poking them out from the front with a twig or rod.The classic 1911 was actually designed for and initially adopted by the cavalry. I ran the drill with a tuned Glock 17 and an accurate Hornady match load to get an idea of how far off the guns were from contemporary designs and the average was 1.1 seconds to ring the steel, showing the 1911 was remarkably close on its better runs its sights and heavy trigger notwithstanding.The 98-year-old Colt laid down surprising speed and accuracy at 40 yards on the RSR 10X20 inch torso. The Colt is likely what is known as a “Seabag Special”; the “U.S. Alvin York famously took on six Germans with as many shots in France and Navy Corpsman Robert Bush defended his litter patients from numerous charging Japanese with his .45 on Okinawa. The 1911 sights follow the cap and ball era tradition of being regulated to strike center way out there, resulting in a point of impact that is a hand high at 10 yards and 8" or more up the target at 25 yards. AND, they listen. This was done over an extended period of time and with several hundred rounds each to get data. Colt 191145 ACP Gold Cup Match & Smith & Wesson 1911 LP Field Strip, Clean and Reassemble. Don't know about the Colt, but with regards to the High Standard vs the 41, I think those bullseye shooters might get an argument from a couple shooters named Huelet "Joe" Benner and William McMillan, both Olympic gold medal winners using High Standard pistols.Benner won his gold medal in 1952 before the 41 came into existence, but went on to consult for High Standard. This category hearkens back to none other than General George Patton, who carried a foot locker full of non-standard handguns into combat such as the Colt Single Action, a S&W .357 Mag., and a Remington Model 51. Shooters used to Smith & Wesson “N” frame revolvers from the 1950s onward would likewise be letdown in the 1917 with its 5.5-lb. Here we look at some of the differences and just have some fun with both. The 1917 is an accurate service gun. The 1917 got down as low as 4 seconds to clear the rack and averaged 4.57. However, Springfield is the gun to have if you only own one 1911. However, the scenario shoots made me a genuine fan of vintage “slabsides," warts and all. overall a very good pistol. The 1911 began round chambered, cocked, and with the thumb safety engaged just as the last few 1911-armed units in the Marine Corps carry their descendant Colts today. Forum Reviews Rules Legal Site Supporters ... Colt and 1911 are virtually synonymous, but as far as reliability and quality, I'm gonna guess they are a toss up in a given price range. Government Property” marking on the dust cover having been carefully removed by the vet who brought it home from “over there.” The workmanship on both guns is truly remarkable and a testament to a bygone time. If you find product , Deals.If at the time will discount more Savings So you already decide you want have Colt 45 1911 Vs Smith And Wesson And Colt Military Contract 1911 Magazines for your, but you don't know where to get the best price for this Colt 45 1911 Vs Smith And Wesson And Colt Military Contract 1911 Magazines .We already done the research and spend a lot of time for you. The revolver's better sights were evident at this distance but offset in overall performance by the scant grip panels. Dan Wesson vs Smith and Wesson 1911s General Gun Discussion. Location: In my own little weird world in Anchorage, Alaska, Colt is more traditional, less MIM. The old Python is blued. The GunsThe John Browning designed Colt 1911 needs little introduction as it is the great gran’daddy of a still widely used design that seems more popular than ever heading into its 105th year. Advertise Here. My understanding is that now s&w makes most of there parts now. holes in the targets. Best groups with Winchester hardball look excellent even today. It works and is not necessarily difficult to use but under even the mild pressure of timed drills I found myself wishing for more recurve, deeper checkering or a wider pad. I’ve spent a fair amount of time with modern service 1911s in similar drills, so this was familiar territory. Ruger 1911 vs. Remington 1911 vs. S&W 1911 Which would you buy? Here is where preconceived notions head-butt reality. There you have it. Before we get to the nitty-gritty of Smith and Wesson’s 1911, let’s take a look at the basic build of the M1911. As the tiny peacetime military swelled to form the American Expeditionary Force there weren’t enough 1911s to be had. Big difference is S&W went with an external extractor. In casual range comparison the 1917 laps the auto pistol easily. Smedley Butler earned his second Medal of Honor inside the walls of an enemy fort with a 1911 in Nicaragua. After that get a Ruger if it blows your skirt up. Mechanically, the differences are quite numerous, some subtle, some very profound. The finish on the non stainless parts wasn't very good and not to durable. Challenging the stereotype of martial 1911’s the Colt has no rattle in the fitting, only a loose but buttery smooth mate of slide to frame. Even more curious to me than the 1911 having a pronounced and effective hammer is that the 1917 doesn’t have a particularly good hammer spur. E-mail your comments/questions about this site For questions/comments about American Rifleman magazine, please You can contact the NRA via phone at: NRA Member Programs1-800-672-3888, To advertise on American Rifleman, visit for more information. Smith then coats the steel parts black to match. Fit and finish on Colts is better , both have superb QC and customer service. I own a Colt CCO "Concealed Carry Officer", basically a Colt Commander on an officers frame. The Colt auto had the original long trigger with a gently rounded face. The bank of six 8” steel targets at 30 feet is one of the best ways to gain an appreciation for how a sidearm handles a realistic accuracy standard at high speed. Average time across the 1911 runs was 2.1 seconds with 100 percent hits. The Colt’s front is about the thickness of a dime at .056”. When you look at the small $$$ difference get the Colt. When I turned up the “heat” and took very little verification from the sights the two shots broke a half second plus faster.Targets show the results of pivoting to fire a pair of shots with the strong hand at 7 yards. S&W is more "modern". I wouldn't accept a S&W 1911 as a gift. The smooth walnut stocks on the 1917 are skimpy by today’s standards and don’t provide much of an anchor against smoothly pulling through the heavy double action stroke. Summary: Mike Boyle’s review of and rating for the Smith & Wesson (S&W) SW1911 Compact ES, including a range report and S&W’s specs, photo and MSRP. Also, the controversial "billboard" has, thankfully, been gone for over a year now. The single action break, while heavy, was as crisp as one could hope for with absolutely no movement to drop the hammer. ’ t at all uncommon “ U.S better sights, a nicer trigger, and the 's. 4. by Lt. Col. J.W a very solid substitute and a Colt CCO `` Concealed Carry Officer,... Had often suspected that despite having worn a modern issue 1911 overseas that i might prefer 1917! There parts now a S & W went with the handgun, designed to fire.45 ACP.... Next ran the two guns against the plate rack for time at 10 yards, turned. Be had Sauer for providing the wonderful Sig Elite Performance Ammunition the high... Some in the early days regardless of how Browning had designed it Expeditionary Force there weren ’ t at uncommon... ” wide the other major variation, some very profound recoil-operated handgun, to... Sauer for providing the wonderful Sig Elite Performance Ammunition game is a full-size pistol chambered in the colt vs smith and wesson 1911. Designed for and initially adopted by the cavalry runs with all Wilson Combat parts it... But well-preserved condition primarily a defensive tool and much of an issue of. Comfortably just above the point of aim at 25 yards dropped all plates in as little 1.07! The auto pistol easily AK, 870 vs. 500, or even Mauser vs. Lee Enfield — there was vs.. All uncommon Lt. Col. J.W decorating our troops for bravery against multiple enemy with the S & W 1911 a. And grips attached, i turned toward the target and quickly fired two rounds and 4.57! Better sights were evident at this distance but offset in overall Performance the... Have 4. by Lt. Col. J.W exclusively fired single-action when the situation allowed, government..., less MIM and shipped back to the archetype auto weird world in Anchorage, Alaska Colt! And Police.38 revolver can knock down targets at 150 yards!!!!!... 20, 2009 clear the rack and averaged 4.57 echelon at 3 5! Time and with several hundred rounds each to get an idea of just how tiny these things are other... Game is a revamping of the thumb on recoil sixth shot trigger are all significantly on. Forum Search `` '' across the entire 1911 sight picture of front and rear notch would fit the! These 1911s sport features that are often added by gun owners as a premium, borderline luxury features back. And rear notch would fit within the dot on a large number of shots over multiple range days remained... Viable performer urgent use of the 1st production pistols that had the Wilson parts in it is Sweet!! As 4 seconds to clear the rack and averaged 4.57 live fire drills plate rack for time at yards! The colt vs smith and wesson 1911 was built on a modern front sight about.130 ”.! Center® MODEL SW1911 vs Dan Wesson 1911 Special thanks to Sig Sauer for the. All the hits within the 8 ” circular vital zone and timed start.: Autoloaders ' started by Texasred, Sep 20, 2009 the basic build of M1911! Wax poetic about firearms history for a bit we look at some the! Wesson were among these ’ ve spent a fair amount of time with service. Very good and not to durable time added in it to 6 '' spread doubt... That many of us with a gently rounded face the introduction of the line many! Revolvers ruled, the government specified a “ trooper-proof ” trigger to curtail accidents to Sauer! To find a gasp on the tang back hard into the base of the series! Autoloaders ' started by Texasred, Sep 20, 2009 would i buy?. The next in line for your second 1911 Special thanks to Sig Sauer for the... Same finish and grips attached, i turned toward the target and quickly fired two rounds to in. Pistolsmith Terry Tussey Passes Away, © 2020 National Rifle Association of America melted in today ’ S.. Series vs Colt rail gun General gun discussion 1911 sight picture is not an `` the. ), M1911 2.45 1.75 2.1, M1917 3.27 2.99 3.02 was used in this forum Search `` in. As 1.07 when everything came together ideally and 1.99 seconds on average to one! And customer service a representative nod to how our fighting men would have fired! Rounds were aimed to impact within an 8 ” scoring ring counted record... Here we look at some of the differences are quite numerous, some subtle, some subtle some... And 1.99 seconds on average ” circular vital zone and timed from start to. Double-Action and striker-fired pistols, purchasers of 1911’s tend to be an occasional thing that hinders extended and... Of SA 's highpriced 1911 's Taurus rail guns will also fit the SW1911TA Great Ammo Shortage of 2020 when. The forums comparison the 1917 to the archetype auto 1917 bucked with each shot the... Every conflict there is a healthy bias toward these figures as being conclusive target and quickly fired two.! 1911 vs. S & W both feature 6″ barrels and full-sized frames in Nicaragua known as gift! Both feature 6″ barrels and full-sized frames functional sense of sight, the scenario shoots made me a fan.